Does a PEA Include Protected Species Surveys?
A Preliminary Ecological Appraisal (PEA) does not usually include detailed protected species surveys. Instead, it provides an initial assessment of a development site’s habitats, ecological features and potential to support protected or notable species.
The purpose is to identify potential ecological constraints and establish whether further investigation may be needed before a planning application can be determined.
Understanding this distinction is important when budgeting for ecological work and planning a development. Although a PEA can identify the potential presence of protected species, it does not necessarily confirm whether they are present or establish the full implications for a proposed project.
What Does a Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Include?
A PEA generally involves an ecological desk study and a site visit.
The desk study examines available ecological information for the development site and its surroundings. Depending on the location and scope of the assessment, this may include records of protected species, notable species, priority habitats and designated sites.
The site visit allows the ecologist to assess the habitats present and identify features that may have ecological value.
These could include:
- Trees and buildings with potential to support bats.
- Ponds and surrounding habitats that may be suitable for great crested newts.
- Hedgerows, woodland and other features that could support protected or notable species.
- Grassland, scrub and other habitats that may be affected by the proposed works.
- Connections between habitats within and beyond the development site.
The findings help the ecologist identify potential ecological constraints and determine whether more detailed surveys are appropriate.
A PEA can therefore provide an important starting point for understanding the ecological considerations associated with a development, but it does not replace every form of ecological investigation.
What Is the Difference Between a PEA and a Protected Species Survey?
The main difference is the scope and purpose of the assessment.
A PEA considers the site’s overall ecological characteristics. It identifies habitats and features of interest, reviews relevant records and assesses the potential for protected species to be present.
A protected species survey investigates a particular species or group of species in greater detail. The methods used depend on the species, the site and the questions that need to be answered.
For example, a PEA may identify a building with features suitable for bat roosting. This could lead to a recommendation for further bat assessment to establish whether a roost is present and whether the proposed works could affect it.
Similarly, a PEA may identify ponds and suitable terrestrial habitat that could support great crested newts. Further assessment may then be needed to establish whether the species is present and what implications this could have for the development.
The need for further surveys depends on the findings of the initial appraisal and the potential effects of the proposed works.
When Might Further Protected Species Surveys Be Required?
Additional surveys may be recommended where the PEA identifies habitats or features that could support protected species and where further information is needed to assess potential impacts.
Common examples include:
Bats – Buildings, bridges and trees may contain potential roosting features. Where appropriate, further assessment may be needed before demolition, conversion or tree works can proceed.
Great crested newts – and suitable surrounding habitats may indicate the potential for great crested newts to be present. Depending on the site and proposed works, further investigation may be required.
Badgers – Evidence of badger activity or features that could provide suitable shelter may need further assessment where development could affect them.
Breeding birds – Trees, hedgerows, scrub and buildings may provide nesting opportunities. Where works could affect nesting birds, the relevant ecological and legal considerations need to be addressed.
These are examples rather than an exhaustive list. Other species may be relevant depending on the site’s location, habitats and proposed development.
Importantly, identifying potential habitat does not automatically mean a protected species is present or that a particular survey will always be required. The ecologist considers the available evidence, the suitability of the habitat and the potential impacts of the proposed works.
Can You Submit a Planning Application Before Protected Species Surveys Are Complete?
Whether a planning application can proceed without completed protected species surveys depends on the circumstances and the ecological information required by the local planning authority.
Where there is a reasonable likelihood of protected species being affected, sufficient information may be needed to assess the potential impacts before planning permission is granted.
A local planning authority may therefore require further ecological information before determining an application. In some circumstances, a planning condition may be appropriate for matters that can legitimately be addressed at a later stage. However, it should not be assumed that surveys can always be postponed until after permission is granted.
This is particularly important where the presence of a protected species could materially affect the feasibility or design of the proposed development.
Commissioning a PEA early can help establish the likely survey requirements and identify potential seasonal restrictions before they affect the planning programme.
Is a PEA the Same as an Ecological Impact Assessment?
No. A Preliminary Ecological Appraisal and an Ecological Impact Assessment (EcIA) have different purposes.
A PEA provides an initial assessment of a site’s ecological characteristics and identifies potential constraints that may need further investigation.
An EcIA is a more detailed process for assessing the likely ecological effects of a proposed development, evaluating their significance and identifying appropriate measures to avoid, reduce or compensate for adverse effects where necessary.
Not every project requires a separate EcIA. The appropriate level of assessment depends on the proposal, the site’s ecological characteristics and the potential effects identified.
A PEA can help determine whether further ecological assessment is necessary and inform the next stages of the planning process.
How Can Collington Winter Environmental Help?
Understanding which ecological assessments your project requires can help you plan the work needed to support a planning application.
Collington Winter Environmental provides Preliminary Ecological Appraisals and other ecological services to help landowners, developers and planning professionals identify potential constraints and understand the next steps.
If you are unsure whether a PEA will be sufficient for your development or whether protected species surveys may be needed, contact us via our contact form below or email a brief summary of your development to info@collingtonwinter.co.uk to discuss your site and proposed works.
Contact Us
Registered Address
23 Bark Street East, 1st Floor, Bolton, BL1 2BQ
Cambridge Office
Future Business Centre, Cambridge Campus, Kings Hedges Road, Cambridge, CB4 2HY
Leicester Office
Rutland House, 23-25 Friar Lane, Leicester, LE1 5QQ
Bristol Office
Newminster House, 27-29 Baldwin Street, Bristol, BS1 1LT
Telephone
Head Office: 01204 939 608
Dumfries Office: 01387 378208